Customer operations review

The business has moved on.
The operation hasn't.

An intensive review of your customer operation that tells you what to fix first and why.

10 days
with your team and your data
1 price
fixed, so you know what it costs before you start
3 angles
people, process and technology
“Richard reviewed our customer operation from end to end and designed a new operating model covering everything from first enquiry through to alumni. He combines senior-level thinking with a willingness to get stuck in, and that combination is hard to find.”
Chief Student Officer, University of East London

Your customers never see how you're set up.

They just feel it.

Sound familiar?
The queue that never quite clears
Customers who get in touch again and again about the same thing
Complaints that keep creeping up
Your best people burning out or leaving
The new system that was meant to fix it all, and didn't
More spent on service every year, and it isn't getting better
The review

I look at all three together

A problem in any one of them nearly always shows up in the other two.

People

How the work is shared out, who does what, and the skills, pressure and mood on the floor.

Process

The journeys that bring in most of your contact, and how well they work for customers, the business and your team.

Technology

Whether your systems help or get in the way, and whether you're getting what you pay for.

See exactly what you get →

Work

Where I've done it

In-house, outsourced and mixed teams, from a national charity to the London Olympics.

Is it right for you?

This is for owners and leaders of growing businesses who

  • want a straight answer on how well their customer operation is working
  • have somewhere between 10 and 100 people looking after customers
  • run their operation in-house, outsourced or a mix

There's nobody to hire and nothing long-term to sign up to, just an honest, independent view within a month, at a fixed price.

I'm commercially minded, and I get on with operational people because I've been one.

I'll give you a straight answer, with the evidence behind it.

The review

10 days. One fixed price.

Working on site, remotely or a mix of the two, I spend 10 days with you over a month, starting with your team and the data you already have.

What I look at

People

I sit down with the team and the people who manage them, look at how the work is shared out and who does what, and get a feel for the skills, the pressure and the mood.

Process

I follow the journeys that bring in most of your contact and look at how well they work for your customers, for the business and for the people running them.

Technology

I look at whether your systems help your customers and your team or get in their way, and whether you're getting what you pay for.

Then I bring the three together into a single picture, with a clear order of what to change and why.

A problem in any one of them nearly always shows up in the other two.

That's why I look at all three together.

What you get

So you know what you're buying before you sign anything, here's exactly what you get.

01.A half-day session to take you through what I've found, so your leadership team can agree priorities there and then
02.Where your repeat and avoidable contact is coming from, so you can take out work that shouldn't be there and free up your team
03.A summary of what's working and what isn't across people, process and technology, so you know what to leave alone, what to change first and what can wait
04.A clear picture of your people, from structure, roles and skills to management and where the team's time goes, so you know whether you have the right people doing the right work
05.A walk-through of the journeys that drive most of your contact and where they break down, so you can focus on the ones that matter most to your customers
06.A look at your technology and how well it serves your team and your customers, so you know whether you're getting what you pay for before you spend any more
The price

One fixed price covers all six outputs, so you know what it costs before you start.

The review. 10 days.

£9,500

I invoice half at the start and half at the end, with travel and expenses charged at cost. The findings are yours to keep.

If you'd like help with what comes next, from making the changes to choosing systems, resourcing models or coaching programmes, I'm happy to quote for it separately.

“Richard brought structure to the programme from the outset, setting out a clear scope, governance and ways of working that gave everyone a shared sense of direction. He’s organised, reliable and easy to work with, and I’d gladly work with him again.”
Owner, Cyber Panda Consulting
Project Manager, University of East London programme
What I'll need from you

I work with what you've already got, so there's nothing to build from scratch, but I will need a few things from you.

01.Someone senior to sponsor the review, who can get me the data and the people
02.A chat before I start about the data you have, so we can agree what you'll send and when
03.A short briefing on anything I should be aware of, and on how you'd like to introduce me to the team
04.An hour with your agents in small groups, and time with team leaders and managers
05.Half a day from your sponsor to go through what I've found
After the review

Want a hand with what comes next?

Some clients take the findings and run with them. Others want help. Either is fine, and I'll quote separately for anything you'd like.

Making the changes

Working alongside your team to put the priorities into practice.

Choosing systems

Working out what you actually need before you commit to a new platform.

Resourcing models

In-house, outsourced or a mix, and how to make whichever you choose work.

Coaching programmes

Building the skills of the team leaders and managers who keep things running.

Work

Where I've done it

In-house, outsourced and mixed teams across charities, retail, telecoms and the biggest sporting event this country has hosted.

The full list
Charities Aid Foundation

Growth without extra headcount

Charitable distributions grew from £100m to £250m a year. The team absorbed it without a single extra hire, while complaints halved.

Role
Director of Customer Operations
Dates
2021 to 2024
Team
The whole customer operation
Regulators
The FCA, HMRC and the Charity Commission
The numbers
£250m
a year going out to charities, up from £100m
0
extra headcount to absorb the growth
50%
fewer complaints, with faster responses
65%
less processing time for UK charities
Where I started

With the money flowing through CAF growing fast, the customer operation had to keep up without growing with it. I ran the whole operation for CAF's clients, overseen by the FCA, HMRC and the Charity Commission.

What I did

Redesigned how the work flowed

Workforce management and process redesign improved performance against service levels by 15% and efficiency by 20%, with no new hires.

Made charities wait less

Better use of technology and a revised compliance framework cut processing time for UK charities by 65% and made payouts 50% faster.

A new vetting framework made payouts to overseas charities 50% faster too, without loosening the rules.

Built a financial crime team from nothing

I made the case to the board against early pushback from the executive, using peer benchmarking, workforce modelling and costings.

The team was fully operational in under six months, paid for by capacity freed up elsewhere.

Cleared a major account review

We reviewed tens of thousands of corporate and consumer accounts within two years, on time and under budget.

Ranking every case by risk and urgency rather than date, I ran an outsourced partner alongside our in-house team with no disruption to client relationships.

Kept a major client

Redesigning the processes and support behind a FTSE 100 bank's corporate giving programme kept the contract at CAF.

Grew the people

Apprenticeships, a coaching framework and roles with real career paths saw staff survey scores rise every year.

Under pressure

Knowing when to say no

Sitting on the management committees below board level, I recommended delaying the launch of a new online portal for thousands of customers when testing showed it wasn't ready to go live.

Winning the argument

The financial crime investment started with the executive against it. I won it on evidence and kept the relationships intact.

Recognition
  • ICA Advanced Certificate in Anti-Money Laundering, gained to lead the new function
  • Board-level reporting on performance, risk and transformation
What I took from it

Growth doesn't have to mean more people.

Fix how the work flows and the same team goes further.

In your review

I look at how the work is shared out, where the time goes and which processes create work they shouldn't, so you can grow without simply adding people.

How the review works →

Charities Aid Foundation

The turnaround

I inherited a knowledgeable team held back by slow, over-checked processes. It won Institute of Customer Service ServiceMark accreditation at the first attempt, in the top quartile.

Role
Head of Customer Service and Experience
Dates
2015 to 2021
Team
Front and back office customer service
Starting point
Slow, over-checked processes
The numbers
50%
less back-office processing time
1st
attempt at ServiceMark, within a year
75
Net Promoter Score, held consistently
35%
fewer internal handoffs
Where I started

When I joined, the team knew charities inside out, but a habit of adding checks after every failure had slowed everything down. Written replies could take up to a fortnight.

What I did

Fixed the processes first

I reviewed every process to find one best way of doing it. That took us from more than 1,000 processes and handoffs to fewer than 650, cut internal handoffs by 35% and halved back-office processing time.

Gave the team one voice

We defined a CAF tone of voice, which improved first time resolution by 25%.

Fixed the phone routing

Better phone routing lifted service levels by 15%.

A new email system with a knowledge base and templates made the team 20% more efficient.

Made bereavement kinder

I redesigned how we handle the accounts of people who have died, with a named owner for every case, specialist training and a dedicated line.

Cases that took weeks took days, and complaints about them fell by 75%.

Did more with the same

A first contact resolution programme built with the front office teams lifted productivity by 20%.

Built the team up

I introduced CAF's first formal induction, a new knowledge base and recognition schemes, and coached people into senior roles of their own.

Under pressure

When the platform went down

A public appeal after the Grenfell Tower fire overwhelmed the donation platform. We had it back within eight hours and kept donations flowing.

When a launch wasn't ready

I wouldn't sign off a new online form until the process behind it changed, then helped redesign it to cut predicted processing time from two days to one.

Recognition
  • ServiceMark accreditation at the first attempt, in the top quartile, against a usual two years or more
  • Staff survey scores up year on year
  • Best in sector at the Top 50 awards, 2019
  • Promoted to Director on the back of the turnaround
What I took from it

Most service problems are really process failures showing up as customer contact.

Fix the process and the contact goes away.

In your review

This is where the review starts. I trace where your repeat and avoidable contact is coming from, so you can see the work that shouldn't be there in the first place.

How the review works →

The University of East London

Finding the failure demand

Brought in by the Chief Student Officer, I found that around 27% of more than 500,000 contacts a year were repeats. I designed an operating model for the whole student journey, which the university is now taking forward.

Role
Customer service transformation consultant
Dates
2025 to 2026
Reporting to
The executive board
Scale
500,000+ interactions a year, five channels
The numbers
27%
of contacts were repeats
500k+
interactions a year across five channels
75%
fewer requests for an adviser in webchat testing
3 to 1
chatbots scoped into one AI webchat
Where I started

The service handled more than 500,000 interactions a year by phone, face to face, email, webchat and webform. I interviewed teams across the service and watched the work happen.

What I did

Found the failure demand

Around 27% of contacts were repeats, and 20% to 25% were handled twice. Most of it came from errors in handoffs and unclear ownership.

Widened the brief

I persuaded the executive to look at the whole student journey, from first enquiry to alumni, rather than one stage.

Designed the new model

A new operating model covering structure, processes and technology, which the university is now taking forward.

It includes a full directorate structure, nine job descriptions and a scorecard for every role.

Changed what gets measured

I replaced activity measures with repeat contact rate, wait time and customer effort after resolution, and sized teams against very seasonal demand.

Joined up the channels

I scoped merging three chatbots into one AI webchat run by one team. Testing showed 90% to 95% accuracy, 80% satisfaction and 75% fewer requests for an adviser.

International telephony moved onto a contact centre platform, and I led the introduction of queue management for the enrolment peak.

Recognition
  • Engagement extended beyond its original term
What they said
“Richard reviewed our customer operation from end to end and designed a new operating model covering everything from first enquiry through to alumni. He combines senior-level thinking with a willingness to get stuck in, and that combination is hard to find.”
Chief Student Officer, University of East London
“Richard brought structure to the programme from the outset, setting out a clear scope, governance and ways of working that gave everyone a shared sense of direction. He’s organised, reliable and easy to work with, and I’d gladly work with him again.”
Owner, Cyber Panda Consulting
Project Manager, University of East London programme
What I took from it

An outside view is the quickest way to see what's really going on.

Sometimes you need someone with no stake in the answer.

In your review

The review gives you that outside view within a month, starting with where your repeat and avoidable contact comes from.

How the review works →

ASOS

Asking why customers got in touch

I led a 300-strong, round-the-clock, multilingual team. Digging into why customers got in touch lifted satisfaction by a fifth.

Role
Head of Customer Operations
Dates
2014 to 2015
Team
300 people, 24/7, multilingual
Budget
£10.5m
The numbers
+20%
customer satisfaction
300
people, 24/7, in several languages
30s
off every contact through coaching
20%
less absence
Where I started

Customers in many countries were getting in touch by email, social media and phone, around the clock. The team was answering contact, but not always asking why it was coming in.

What I did

Found out why people got in touch

Keyword analysis of the CRM data and contact driver analysis got us to the root causes, and we fixed them. Customer satisfaction rose by 20%.

Spotted problems early

I built reporting that combined keywords, volumes, contact types and survey results, so we could see new issues in near real time.

Coached, not just managed

A new coaching framework took 30 seconds off every contact.

Looked after the team

An absence plan cut absence by more than 20%.

Made 24/7 really 24/7

I redesigned the service model for true round-the-clock global cover and sorted out cross-border delivery and returns problems.

What I took from it

The best answer is the one the customer never has to ask for.

Ask why they got in touch, not just how fast you replied.

In your review

I follow the journeys that drive most of your contact and show you where they work and where they don't, so you can fix causes rather than symptoms.

How the review works →

Sainsbury's

Getting more from an outsourced partner

I got an outsourced Careline resourced to match its demand, and set up social media service that resolved issues in under 30 minutes, when retail social service was still new.

Role
Careline Contact Centre Manager
Dates
2013 to 2014
Operation
160 seats, outsourced
Budget
£4m
The numbers
<30
minutes to resolve on Twitter and Facebook
160
seat outsourced contact centre
4
channels across phone, social media, email and post
5
person team for the Chief Executive and Chairman
Where I started

The Careline was run by an outsourced partner that set its own resourcing levels, so at times we were paying for capacity we didn't need.

What I did

Brought the store into the contact centre

Part of the work was helping the team understand the store experience customers were calling about.

Built social service early

I designed and launched a social media centre of excellence with its own contact strategy, resolving issues in under 30 minutes across Twitter and Facebook.

Let the data fix the website

Contact analysis showed which questions kept coming in, so we reorganised the website FAQs around them.

Agreed the right resourcing

I reviewed the data with the partner, agreed new resourcing levels and moved the spare frontline capacity into back-office work that needed it.

Handled contact at the very top

I led a team of five handling every executive complaint and letter for the Chief Executive and Chairman.

What I took from it

Cost per resolution matters far more than cost per contact.

A quick reply that fixes nothing just comes back.

In your review

I look at whether your channels and systems help your team resolve things or just move contact around, and whether you're getting what you pay for.

How the review works →

London 2012

A deadline that couldn't move

I designed and ran the contact centre for the Olympic and Paralympic Games from a standing start. It met its service levels, came in £200k under budget and became a model for other major sporting events.

Role
Contact Centre Vendor Manager
Dates
2010 to 2012
Operation
Up to 150 seats, outsourced
Customers
Volunteers, staff and the public
The numbers
£200k
under budget
150
seats at peak, through an outsourced partner
2
Games, Olympic and Paralympic
Where I started

There was no contact centre to inherit. Volunteers, paid staff and the public all needed help, and the deadline was fixed in front of the whole world.

What I did

Designed it from scratch

I designed and put in place the operating model, processes, policies and procedures from a standing start.

Ran it through a partner

I managed an outsourced operation of up to 150 seats through go-live and into steady state, holding standards through peak demand and consistently meeting service levels.

Measured what mattered

I built quality and performance frameworks based on how much effort customers had to put in, and reported monthly to the Board.

Left something behind

Other major global sporting events went on to adopt the operating model.

Recognition
  • Operating model adopted by other major global sporting events
What I took from it

In-house, outsourced or a mix, the model matters less than whether it's run well.

A partner is only as good as the brief.

In your review

Whether you run service in-house, outsourced or a mix, I look at how the work is shared out, who does what and how well it's managed.

How the review works →

Richard McCarthy

You'll be working with me from start to finish.

No juniors and no handovers.

Why I set this up

Having started out consulting at Accenture, I spent most of my career running customer operations myself.

That's meant telecoms, retail, the London 2012 Games and ten years at a national charity, where I went from Head of Customer Service to running the whole customer operation as Director. I've led teams of up to 300 people and run in-house, outsourced and mixed operations, under regulators as demanding as the FCA.

Again and again I saw the same thing. The business had moved on and the operation hadn't, and leaders could feel it in the numbers but couldn't get a straight answer on what to fix first. I set up customer ops, sorted to give them one.

I'm commercially minded, and I get on with operational people because I've been one.

I'll tell you what I think, with the evidence behind it, even if it's not what you were hoping to hear.

Four things I've learned
01.Most service problems are really process failures.
02.Cost per resolution matters far more than cost per contact.
03.Technology on its own is rarely the whole answer.
04.An outside view is the quickest way to see what's really going on.
Recognition and credentials
  • Institute of Customer Service ServiceMark for CAF, at the first attempt and in the top quartile
  • Promoted from Head of Customer Service to Director at CAF
  • Best in sector at the Top 50 awards, 2019
  • ICA Advanced Certificate in Anti-Money Laundering and Counter Terrorist Financing
My career

Most of it spent on the operational side, which is why I know what a busy floor feels like.

2025 to 2026
Consulting

Customer service transformation at the University of East London, reporting to the executive board

Case study →
2021 to 2024
Charities Aid Foundation

Director of Customer Operations, running the whole customer operation

Case study →
2015 to 2021
Charities Aid Foundation

Head of Customer Service and Experience

Case study →
2014 to 2015
ASOS

Head of Customer Operations, 300 people, 24/7 and multilingual

Case study →
2013 to 2014
Sainsbury's

Careline Contact Centre Manager, a 160-seat outsourced operation

Case study →
2010 to 2012
London 2012

Contact Centre Vendor Manager for the Olympic and Paralympic Games

Case study →
2007 to 2009
Accenture

Senior Consultant, CRM practice. A 25% productivity gain for a major mobile operator and a £250k outsourcing saving for a water company

2000 to 2007
Telecoms

Head of Customer Service for Bulldog broadband at Cable & Wireless, and Customer Operations Manager at T-Mobile

Get in touch

Let's have a chat

If this sounds like your operation, let's talk about what's going on and whether the review is right for you, with no obligation either way.

If this sounds like your operation, let's have a chat. No obligation either way.

Get in touch